What a cancellation process actually is
A cancellation process is everything between a customer deciding to leave and the charge stopping. That includes where the cancel button lives, what you ask before you accept the request, how fast you process it, and what you confirm afterward. The FTC has brought numerous cases alleging that hiding cancellation mechanisms is unfair or deceptive.
For a gym, an app, or a SaaS seller, the process is also a business decision. Commenters on the FTC's rule said they often resort to disputing the subscription charge with credit card companies because cancellation is so difficult. See disputing a subscription charge for how that plays out.
The legal baseline today
The federal statute that governs you is ROSCA, the Restore Online Shoppers' Confidence Act. It requires simple mechanisms for a consumer to stop recurring charges in online negative option sales, and it is current law. On top of it sit state statutes, also current.
The FTC's 2024 click-to-cancel amendments are a different story. The FTC published its amended Negative Option Rule in the Federal Register on November 15, 2024. Then, on July 8, 2025, the Eighth Circuit sided with the petitioners. It vacated the amended Negative Option Rule in Custom Communications v. FTC, No. 24-3137. The FTC then issued a conforming final rule. It was published at 91 FR 6507 and took effect February 12, 2026. It put the rule back the way it read before the 2024 version took effect. The FTC sought public comment on further amendments in a notice dated March 13, 2026. That notice sits at 91 FR 12318. Comments were due April 13, 2026. That notice is not law. So the amendments bind no one today. Read the FTC click-to-cancel rule vacated for the full history.
Here is the catch. The vacated amendments showed what the FTC thinks is fair. They are not law. Meeting them proves nothing under ROSCA or a state statute.
Findability
The vacated rule said a simple cancellation mechanism must be easy to find. The FTC's research found that confusing labels delayed consumers trying to finish cancellation tasks on some sites. Some sites put the path under titles like "auto-renew" or "edit plan" instead of plain terms. The FTC said such sites need more intuitive labeling.
Here is the fix. Put a "Cancel" or "Cancel subscription" button in account or settings. Put it in the same menu where the customer manages billing. Do not bury it under a label that describes a different task. A customer looking to cancel should find the path in seconds, without a support ticket.
Same-medium cancellation
The core principle: if they signed up online, they cancel online. Under the vacated rule, a consumer had to get a cancellation path in the same medium as enrollment. Someone who enrolls online must get an equally simple online way to cancel. It also said an online enrollee cannot be forced to talk to an agent or chat rep to cancel. That is, unless the seller required the same to enroll.
For sellers who sign people up by phone or in person, the rule was flexible. A seller who got consent in person must also offer cancellation online or by telephone, at the seller's choice. Sellers with no website can take cancellations by phone. They just need to follow the simple phone rules. Email can also serve as an online cancellation method.
Symmetry
Cancellation must be as easy as enrollment in four dimensions: time, burden, expense, and ease of use. The vacated rule said this plainly. The FTC also noted that a simple online signup implies an equally simple cancel path.
Test your own flow against your signup flow. If signup takes two clicks and no phone call, cancellation should not take a form, a call, and a wait. If signup is free, cancellation should not carry a fee. If signup works at midnight, cancellation should too.
What you may ask before cancelling
You may check who they are, confirm the account, and confirm they mean to cancel. The vacated rule allowed exactly that. But it drew a line. These steps must not make cancel much harder than signup. The rule said any such step that creates unreasonable asymmetry violates section 5 of the FTC Act and the rule. The FTC declined to create a safe harbor for sellers using verification tools to thwart or delay cancellation. It also said a two-factor check is more than sufficient to ensure the correct person is cancelling.
Prompt processing
Once the customer clicks or calls, act fast. The vacated rule said sellers must effectuate cancellation promptly, whether or not they answer the call in person. It also said phone cancellation cannot be open only at hours so awkward that they block people from cancelling. Normal business hours are the hours in which you would normally engage with customers. An answering machine works if it clearly lets subscribers cancel and leave their details. Do not charge any needless or unfair cost for a cancellation call.
One more point from the vacated rule: cancellation applies only to the negative option part of a contract. If the customer has a separate term commitment, its terms continue until that agreement expires. Do not use that as a trap. State clearly what stops and what continues.
Retention done right
You may show an offer during cancellation. You may not block the exit. California's law, covered below, allows a discount offer during online cancellation. The click-to-cancel link must stay on screen the whole time. That is the right model everywhere.
The honest retention play is fixing the reason the customer gives. Price complaint? Offer the discount. Usage complaint? Offer a pause or a lighter plan. Wrong features? Offer the right tier. A customer who leaves over price and stays on a discount is a saved revenue stream. A customer who leaves over a broken feature stays if you fix it. Blocking the door saves no one and generates chargebacks. See cancellation flow for how to design this path. See why free trials are not free for how honest trials cut later cancellations.
California's Automatic Renewal Law
California is the state to watch on how cancellation must work. Its automatic renewal law covers sections 17600 through 17606. If a consumer can accept a renewal online, the business must let them cancel online, at will. The method can be a prominently located direct link or button in the account, profile, or device settings. The business must act promptly when the consumer uses the link. It must also act promptly on a phone call once the consumer says "cancel". The law also allows a termination email. The business must provide it, and the consumer can send it without adding any information.
California also requires clear notice of any material change to renewal terms, and of how to cancel. A notice must say the renewal will happen unless the consumer cancels. It has to list at least one way the consumer can cancel. Any electronic notice has to carry a link to the cancellation process. Free trials must be cancellable before the consumer pays. See California click-to-cancel law and click-to-cancel law states for how other states compare.
A cancellation process you can set up this week
- Audit findability. Open your app as a customer and time how long it takes to find "Cancel". If it is not in account or settings under a plain label, fix that first.
- Match the medium. Online signup gets an online cancel path. In-person signup gets phone or online, your choice.
- Check symmetry. Compare clicks, time, cost, and hours between signup and cancel. Cancel must be no harder on any measure.
- Set your verification bar. One authentication step, no more. Two-factor is the ceiling, not the floor.
- Wire prompt processing. A cancel request should stop the next charge immediately, not at the end of a queue. Route after-hours calls to an answering machine. It should record the request plus the caller's name and account details.
- Add one retention offer beside the cancel button, never in front of it. Show it once, honor a refusal, and log the reason given.
- Confirm in writing. Send an email stating what was cancelled, when charges stop, and what, if anything, continues under an existing term.
- Review monthly. Read the cancellation reasons and fix the top one. That is retention that actually works.
That process is built around ROSCA's simple-mechanism requirement and California's statute, and it keeps the customers worth keeping.
Sources
- Custom Communications, Inc. v. Federal Trade Commission, No. 24-3137, United States Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit (July 8, 2025) (Eighth Circuit) (8th Circuit) (Negative Option Rule) (FTC Act) (Federal Trade Commission Act)
- Rule Concerning the Use of Prenotification Negative Option Plans, Federal Trade Commission advance notice of proposed rulemaking, 91 FR 12318 (Federal Register, March 13, 2026)
- Revision of the Negative Option Rule to Conform to Federal Court Decisions, Federal Trade Commission final rule, 91 FR 6507 (Federal Register, February 12, 2026)
- Negative Option Rule, Federal Trade Commission final rule, 89 FR 90476 (Federal Register, November 15, 2024) (FTC click-to-cancel rule) (Rule Concerning Recurring Subscriptions and Other Negative Option Programs)
- California Business and Professions Code section 17602 (California Automatic Renewal Law), as amended by AB 2863 (Stats. 2024, Ch. 515) (California) (BPC 17602)
A merchant's guide to a cancellation process that follows the law and keeps customers: findability, same-medium access, symmetry, prompt processing, and fair retention.