Renewal Rules Directory ↓

FTC click-to-cancel complaint: the court challenge

As of

Switch within Click-to-cancel rule

What the click-to-cancel complaint actually was

The FTC click-to-cancel complaint was a court challenge to the FTC's amended Negative Option Rule. The FTC published the rule on November 15, 2024. Its full title was the Rule Concerning Recurring Subscriptions and Other Negative Option Programs. It applied to all negative option programs in any media.

Several petitioners asked the Eighth Circuit to review it. The case was Custom Communications, Inc. v. Federal Trade Commission, No. 24-3137. The court decided it on July 8, 2025.

The petitioners challenged the Rule on three grounds and asked the court to vacate it entirely. They argued the Rule went beyond the FTC's legal power. It did not meet the law's specificity and prevalence tests. They argued the Commission never issued the required preliminary regulatory analysis, so the Rule must be set aside.

The Commission said the Rule was well tailored and backed by strong evidence. The court denied petitioners' motion for a stay of the Rule pending judicial review. Then it vacated the entire Rule.

What the vacated 2024 amendments would have required of sellers

The 2024 amendments would have imposed four obligations on you:

  1. Give consumers a simple way to cancel that stops all recurring charges at once.
  2. Get a consumer's clear yes to the negative option feature before you charge them.
  3. Give consumers key facts before you take their billing details or charge them.
  4. Do not misstate key facts when you market with negative option features.

The Rule also defined failing to get a consumer's express informed consent before charging as unfair or deceptive.

The cancel rule had teeth. A consumer who enrolled online would have been owed an equally simple online cancellation experience. Under the vacated rule, a web-based cancel option could not be buried or confusing. You could not make cancellation harder to use or find than the consent mechanism. The vacated rule also matched the two paths: ending the plan could demand no more effort from the consumer than starting it did. The Rule assumed an online cancellation under it would take no more than 30 seconds to one minute. It assumed a telephone cancellation would take no more than one to two minutes.

None of that is a federal rule for you today. The court vacated it.

Why the court vacated: the procedural failure, not the substance

The Eighth Circuit held that the FTC's process fell short. It also held that this error hurt the petitioners. The Commission skipped the required preliminary regulatory analysis. The court said the Commission's decision to bypass it was not made in bad faith. But the FTC's look at other options was thin. The informal hearing never weighed the costs and benefits of any other approach.

The court said the ordinary practice is to vacate unlawful agency action. It said it could not strike the rule only for the parties who sued. This was because of the breadth of the Rule's coverage. So the court threw out the whole Rule. The FTC's broken process had hurt the petitioners.

Two points matter for you. First, the court wrote that it does not endorse unfair and deceptive practices in negative option marketing. Second, the Rule had a severability clause, but the court still vacated the entire Rule. The older rule below stands because the FTC's conforming final rule restored it.

What still binds you today

The pre-2024 prenotification rule

The FTC's conforming final rule was published at 91 FR 6507 on February 12, 2026. It restored the Negative Option Rule to the form it had before the 2024 Rule became effective. The conforming final rule changes the rule's full name back to Use of Prenotification Negative Option Plans. It requires sellers to state the plan's key terms clearly before consumers subscribe. It requires sellers to promptly honor written requests to cancel. These come from consumers who have met any minimum purchase requirements. A contract-complete subscriber is one who has purchased the minimum quantity of merchandise. The terms of membership require this quantity. You must not ship substituted merchandise without the express consent of the subscriber.

This rule is narrow. It covers prenotification plans. Today the rule covers no other kind of negative option. It does not reach most modern subscription marketing.

ROSCA

The Restore Online Shoppers' Confidence Act is current law. The vacated Rule itself said its substantive requirements already exist under section 5 of the FTC Act, ROSCA, or the TSR. ROSCA requires clear disclosure of material terms and express informed consent before charging in online negative option sales.

State statutes

State automatic renewal laws did not pause when the federal rule fell. California's Automatic Renewal Law says a business must give an acknowledgment with the offer terms, cancellation policy, and how to cancel. A notice must state the renewal will happen unless the consumer cancels. An electronic notice must include a link to the cancellation process, and give one or more ways the consumer can cancel. See our page on the California click-to-cancel law. See Colorado's law too.

New York's law says a business may not obstruct, delay or place unreasonable conditions on a consumer's request to cancel. The attorney general may ask a court for an injunction and restitution when a business breaks the law.

Card network rules

Visa's rules say a merchant must show clear cancellation and refund policies and a means for the cardholder to easily cancel transactions. Visa also requires clear disclosure that the cardholder will be charged unless they cancel. And it requires instructions for an easy way to cancel the agreement or any later charges.

Mastercard's guide says a cardholder can dispute a recurring transaction when the merchant kept billing after being told to cancel. A cardholder can dispute a recurring transaction that was canceled before billing. An issuer can also dispute a charge if it told the merchant or acquirer to cancel first. Visa's rules let an issuer start a dispute under Dispute Condition 13.2. That applies when a cardholder withdrew permission to charge the card, and the merchant billed it anyway.

The 2026-03-13 comment request: what it is and what it is not

On March 13, 2026, the FTC published an advance notice of proposed rulemaking at 91 FR 12318. The notice says the Commission seeks comments on whether it should use its FTC Act power to modernize the Rule. It also asks whether the Negative Option Rule needs amendments.

It is a request for comment, and nothing in it binds you today. The notice says negative option practices have remained a persistent source of consumer harm. It says the amendments would help consumers avoid recurring payments they did not mean to order.

What the vacatur means for your cancellation flow in practice

Did all your duties end? No. Is click-to-cancel still law after the Eighth Circuit decision? As a federal rule, no. Related obligations from other sources still apply.

You should still fix your flow. Here is why:

  • The FTC has brought numerous cases alleging that hiding cancellation mechanisms is unfair or deceptive. Section 5 enforcement did not stop with the vacatur.
  • State automatic renewal laws may apply if your subscribers live in those states.
  • Visa and Mastercard rules still apply to recurring charges on their cards.

Do not read the vacatur as permission to add friction. The court itself said it does not endorse unfair and deceptive practices in negative option marketing. Retention work should fix the reasons subscribers leave, not block the exit. See our guide to the cancellation flow and our page on the vacated click-to-cancel rule. Also read why free trials are not free when the trial turns into a charge the customer never meant to make.

The short answer to "do I still need to fix my flow?" is yes. The federal rule you heard about is gone. The duties behind it were never just federal.

Sources

The Eighth Circuit vacated the FTC's click-to-cancel rule on procedure, not substance. Here is what still binds your cancellation flow.