Why subscription disputes are different from one-off purchases
Disputing a subscription charge is not the same as disputing a single purchase. The cardholder is not saying the product was broken or never arrived. They are saying something about the billing itself.
Mastercard's guide names two such grounds. A cardholder can dispute a recurring transaction when the merchant kept billing after they were told to cancel. They can also dispute when they did not know they were agreeing to recurring billing at all.
It means the dispute is not really about the charge. It is about what the customer understood when they signed up. If your checkout page buried the recurring terms, the cardholder may not have known they were agreeing to recurring billing.
What the cardholder must show, and what you can show back
Mastercard's guide says the cardholder's notice to cancel must state the date the cardholder told the merchant to cancel. The cardholder's letter, email, message or dispute form must describe the complaint in enough detail for all parties.
Visa's rules add more requirements on the cardholder's side. An issuer must certify that the cardholder withdrew permission to charge the payment credential. A cardholder must try to resolve the dispute with the merchant before the issuer may start a dispute. And a cardholder must return the merchandise or cancel the services before the issuer may start a dispute.
On your side, Mastercard's guide lists what an acquirer may use to second present the transaction. The responses available include:
- Showing the transaction was not recurring
- Showing you disclosed the recurring transaction and the cardholder did not meet the contract's cancellation terms
- Showing the cardholder used services after the cancellation date
- Showing the cardholder accepted proper disclosure of the recurring transaction
There is also the Payment Cancellation Service. Mastercard's guide says an issuer can dispute a recurring transaction if the account was listed in the Payment Cancellation Service before the disputed transaction. Your acquirer can document that the account was not listed in that service before the transaction. Check with your acquirer on this one.
The evidence that proves a recurring arrangement
If the cardholder claims they never agreed to recurring billing, you need proof they did. Mastercard's guide says compelling evidence for recurring transactions can include the description and date of the initial transaction. It also includes the start date of the recurring payment arrangement.
One strong piece of evidence is the click. Mastercard's guide says merchants can prove a recurring transaction by showing the cardholder clicked to accept the recurring terms. Show a screenshot of your checkout page with the recurring price and billing date. Pair it with a server log of that acceptance.
For non-face-to-face recurring or installment repayment disputes, Mastercard's guide requires a description of the goods or services provided. Keep that description in your response.
Where merchants lose these disputes
One losing response is a bare statement. Mastercard's guide says a merchant statement that the cardholder never contacted the merchant to cancel is not a valid second presentment. Saying "they never called us" is not a valid second presentment.
What counts is documentation. The order form with the recurring terms. The click log showing acceptance. The usage records after the cancellation date. The Payment Cancellation Service check. Without those, your response rests on a statement alone.
If the cardholder escalates: pre-arbitration
Say you win the first round. The cardholder can push back. Mastercard's guide says an issuer may file a pre-arbitration case when the cardholder reasserts that a recurring transaction was cancelled.
There is a limit on that step. Mastercard's guide says pre-arbitration filing is not available when the acquirer provided compelling evidence of cardholder authentication at the start of a recurring payment. If you authenticated the cardholder at the start of the recurring payment, keep that evidence.
The enrollment fixes that prevent the dispute
The best chargeback response is the one you never have to write. That starts at enrollment.
Visa's rules let a merchant prove a trial or promotional purchase was agreed to by showing the cardholder expressly agreed to future transactions. That express agreement is the standard. The cardholder must expressly agree to future transactions.
Visa's rules say a merchant must have notified the cardholder of future transactions before the transaction date. A reminder before the transaction date is one way to meet this. If you run free trials, the same logic applies, and why free trials are not free explains the billing rules around them.
The descriptor fix
Sometimes the cardholder disputes the charge because they do not recognize it. Your statement descriptor is the first line of defense. Stripe's documentation says clear and accurate statement descriptors can reduce chargebacks and disputes. Clear, easy to read statement descriptors matter. They cut confusion and chargebacks.
A descriptor the cardholder does not recognize can lead them to call the bank instead of you. If you want the full picture of what goes into one, see what a payment descriptor is. If you use Stripe, how Stripe statement descriptors work covers the specifics of setting yours.
The cancellation fixes
The other ground for these disputes is the cancellation that did not work. Visa's rules say a merchant must show clear cancellation and refund policies and a means for the cardholder to easily cancel transactions. Visa's rules require instructions for an easy way to cancel the agreement or any subsequent transactions.
This is not optional polish. Commenters said they often resort to disputing the subscription charge with credit card companies because cancellation is so difficult. Cancellation was just too hard. Some cancel by disputing the charge with credit card companies. Others cancel the card altogether. Commenters said hard cancellation leads them to dispute the charge instead.
The fix is a clear cancellation policy and an easy means for the cardholder to cancel. A good cancellation flow does that.
What you may and may not do after a dispute
Once the transaction comes back to you, the rules tighten.
Visa's rules say a merchant must not resubmit a transaction that was disputed and returned to the merchant. You cannot run the charge again.
Visa's rules say a merchant must not require a cardholder to waive the right to dispute a transaction with the issuer. A "no chargebacks" clause in your terms is something Visa's rules forbid you from requiring.
You are not out of options, though. Visa's rules say a merchant may still pursue payment from the customer outside the Visa system after a returned transaction. If the customer does owe the money, you may still pursue it outside the Visa system.
On the amount: Visa's rules limit the dispute amount to the unused part of a cancelled service or the value of returned merchandise. The dispute amount is limited to the unused part of a cancelled service. Visa's rules also say a dispute is invalid when the cardholder cancelled before the expected delivery or service date. And a merchant must process a credit or voided receipt when a cardholder cancels.
Treat the dispute as a signal
A recurring-billing chargeback tells you how your signup and cancellation flow really work. If the cardholder says they never agreed to recurring billing, check your disclosure. If they say they cancelled and you kept billing, check your cancel path. Fix the cause. The FTC published its amended Negative Option Rule in the Federal Register on November 15, 2024. The Eighth Circuit's opinion in Custom Communications v. FTC, No. 24-3137, was filed on July 8, 2025. The Eighth Circuit vacated the FTC's 2024 amendments to the Negative Option Rule. The FTC's conforming final rule was published at 91 FR 6507 on February 12, 2026. After the Eighth Circuit's vacatur, the FTC restored the Negative Option Rule to the form it had before the 2024 Rule became effective. The FTC's advance notice of proposed rulemaking was published at 91 FR 12318 on March 13, 2026. The March notice is a question, not a rule. ROSCA remains in force, as do state laws.
Sources
- Mastercard Chargeback Guide, Merchant Edition (Mastercard)
- Statement descriptors | Stripe Documentation (Stripe)
- Visa Core Rules and Visa Product and Service Rules (Visa)
- Negative Option Rule, Federal Trade Commission final rule, 89 FR 90476 (Federal Register, November 15, 2024) (FTC click-to-cancel rule) (Rule Concerning Recurring Subscriptions and Other Negative Option Programs)
A chargeback on a recurring transaction is a signal about your enrollment and cancellation flow. Here is how these disputes work and how to prevent them.