Who NCTA is and why it weighed in on the FTC's click-to-cancel rule
The NCTA is the trade group for the cable and broadband industry. Its members sell internet, TV and streaming subscriptions, so when the FTC proposed its click-to-cancel rule, the NCTA had a lot at stake. It was among the commenters who pushed back on the rule.
That pushback is useful to you as a subscription seller. Each objection the NCTA raised points at a real compliance question. Read together, its complaints form the clearest checklist available of what a platform seller would have had to build.
NCTA's first objection: the rule ignored third-party sign-up arrangements like Roku, Amazon and Apple
The NCTA said the proposed rule fails to account for third party sign-up arrangements like those with Roku, Amazon, and Apple. Many streaming subscriptions are not sold on the seller's own site. A customer signs up inside a Roku channel, an Amazon app store or an Apple TV subscription screen.
This raised a hard question. If a customer signs up through Roku, who handles the cancel button? If a future federal rule or a state law revives these requirements, you will need an answer for every platform you sell through.
NCTA's second objection: 'clear and conspicuous' does not work on small screens
The NCTA also said the clear and conspicuous definition does not account for small screens. A disclosure that reads fine on a laptop can shrink into a wall of tiny text on a phone.
The lesson for you is simple. Whatever disclosure rules apply to you, test them on the smallest screen your customers use. The FTC's own research found that confusing labels delayed consumers trying to finish cancellation tasks on some sites. Some sites put the cancellation path under titles like auto-renew or edit plan instead of straightforward terms. That is a design failure on any screen size.
NCTA's third objection: mandating cancellation through the same website used to sign up is too prescriptive
The NCTA argued that mandating cancellation through the same website used to start the transaction is too prescriptive. The concern was practical. A customer might sign up on a website but manage the account in an app. Forcing the cancel path back onto the original website can confuse people who live in the app.
The FTC's final rule softened this. It removed the requirement that website cancellation use the same precise means as consent. It also swapped the word internet for a new term, interactive electronic medium. But the core idea stayed. Online sign-ups still needed an online exit just as simple.
NCTA's fourth objection: rigid click-to-cancel requirements and limits on saves would harm consumers
The NCTA was one of the commenters who told the FTC that consumers might not understand the negative consequences of cancellation. Trade groups also said the same-medium rule could make people cancel by mistake.
On saves, the proposed rule had included limits on retention offers during the cancel flow. The final rule removed the treatment of saves in cancellation flows, which the proposed rule had included. Some commenters said the saves provision violated the First Amendment. The FTC rejected that argument. It still dropped the provision.
If you run saves, note the line the FTC drew elsewhere. The vacated rule said a cancel path cannot be harder to use or find than the consent mechanism. Fixing the reason a customer leaves is fair retention. Blocking the exit is not.
What the FTC's since-vacated rule actually said about each of these points
The FTC published the final rule on November 15, 2024. It set clear standards for what sellers must tell customers, and when. It also set standards for simple ways to cancel. It aimed at all recurring charge plans where silence or failure to cancel counts as consent to charges. It covered monthly gym memberships even when members can cancel each month. It also covered automatic renewals and free trial offers.
On cancellation, the rule said a seller must let a consumer cancel through the same medium the consumer used to consent. The cancellation mechanism had to be at least as easy to use as the mechanism used to consent. Canceling had to match signing up in time, burden, cost and ease of use. An online cancellation mechanism had to be easy to find and use.
The rule did allow some friction. A seller could ask a consumer to prove who they are, or confirm they really want to cancel. But those steps could not make cancel much harder than signing up. The rule said any such step that created unreasonable asymmetry violated section 5 of the FTC Act and the rule. The FTC said two-factor authentication is more than enough to prove the right person is cancelling.
The rule also said a seller cannot make an online enrollee talk to an agent or service rep to cancel. Chat counted as a cancel path only for people who enrolled through an agent, virtual or live. And cancelling ended only the negative option piece of a deal, never the full agreement. When a consumer cancels, all terms and conditions continue until the contract or agreement expires.
Where the rule stands now: the vacatur, the conforming rule, and the comment request
Challenges to the rule reached the Eighth Circuit. In Custom Communications v. FTC, No. 24-3137, the court filed its opinion on July 8, 2025. The Eighth Circuit granted the petitions for review and vacated the FTC's 2024 amendments to the Negative Option Rule. The FTC says the amended rule was vacated shortly before businesses would need to comply with all parts of it.
After the Eighth Circuit's vacatur, the FTC restored the Negative Option Rule to the form it had before the 2024 Rule became effective. The FTC's conforming final rule was published at 91 FR 6507 on February 12, 2026. The rule's full name changed back to Use of Prenotification Negative Option Plans.
The FTC is not finished. The FTC's advance notice of proposed rulemaking was published at 91 FR 12318 on March 13, 2026. The FTC's advance notice set April 13, 2026 as the deadline for comments. Nothing in it binds a seller yet. Any new rule may face the same questions the NCTA raised.
What still binds a subscription seller: ROSCA and state automatic renewal laws
The vacatur does not leave you free to hide the cancel button. Section 5(a)(1) of the FTC Act still bans unfair or deceptive acts or practices in commerce. A seller who makes material misrepresentations is being deceptive. The FTC has brought numerous cases alleging that hiding cancellation mechanisms is unfair or deceptive.
ROSCA, the federal Restore Online Shoppers' Confidence Act, also remains in force. It covers online negative option sales and requires clear disclosure of material terms, express informed consent before charging, and simple mechanisms to stop recurring charges.
State automatic renewal laws may apply to you too, and the NCTA's objections protect no one from them. California's Automatic Renewal Law is one, and our state pages cover the others. If you sell in those states, read them before you design your flow.
The NCTA's arguments are a preview, not a shield. A future federal rule or a state law may ask the same questions. Build your cancellation flow to answer them now, and you will not be scrambling later.
Sources
- Custom Communications, Inc. v. Federal Trade Commission, No. 24-3137, United States Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit (July 8, 2025) (Eighth Circuit) (8th Circuit) (Negative Option Rule) (FTC Act) (Federal Trade Commission Act)
- Rule Concerning the Use of Prenotification Negative Option Plans, Federal Trade Commission advance notice of proposed rulemaking, 91 FR 12318 (Federal Register, March 13, 2026)
- Revision of the Negative Option Rule to Conform to Federal Court Decisions, Federal Trade Commission final rule, 91 FR 6507 (Federal Register, February 12, 2026)
- Negative Option Rule, Federal Trade Commission final rule, 89 FR 90476 (Federal Register, November 15, 2024) (FTC click-to-cancel rule) (Rule Concerning Recurring Subscriptions and Other Negative Option Programs)
The cable trade group's complaints against the FTC rule read like a compliance checklist for subscription sellers.