Quick answer: the federal click-to-cancel rule has no force today
Is click to cancel in effect right now? No. The federal click-to-cancel rule carries no legal force right now. On July 8, 2025, the Eighth Circuit vacated the FTC's amended Negative Option Rule. The case was Custom Communications v. Federal Trade Commission, case number 24-3137. The appeals court sided with the challengers and threw out the rule in full.
After the ruling, the FTC put the Negative Option Rule back the way it read before the 2024 changes. The earlier version became operative once more on February 12, 2026. It covers only prenotification plans. The click-to-cancel rule had reached many more subscription types.
As of right now, no federal rule requires one-click cancellation. But that does not mean subscription businesses are off the hook. ROSCA still applies. Laws on automatic renewals in the states remain in force. California's state law still has its own online cancellation duty. This page explains the timeline, what the court said, and what still binds you.
Timeline: how the rule was published, vacated, and rolled back
Here is the short version of what happened, step by step.
November 15, 2024. The FTC put its amended Negative Option Rule in the Federal Register. The FTC gave it the formal name Rule Concerning Recurring Subscriptions and Other Negative Option Programs. People called it the click-to-cancel rule.
July 8, 2025. The Eighth Circuit filed its opinion in Custom Communications v. FTC. The Eighth Circuit agreed with the petitioners and set the amended rule aside. According to the FTC, the ruling landed just ahead of the date when companies would have had to meet every part of the rule.
February 12, 2026. The FTC's conforming final rule, published at 91 FR 6507, became operative. That action returned the Negative Option Rule to its pre-2024 wording. Its formal title reverted to Use of Prenotification Negative Option Plans.
March 13, 2026. The FTC issued an advance notice of proposed rulemaking at 91 FR 12318. It asks for public comment on whether the agency should amend the rule again. The comment deadline was April 13, 2026. Nothing that emerges from this process binds anyone at this point.
Why the Eighth Circuit vacated the rule
The court's reason was procedural.
The Eighth Circuit vacated the rule because the FTC broke the FTC Act's required steps for rulemaking. The Commission skipped a required step. It never issued a preliminary regulatory analysis. That analysis is a required step in the rulemaking process.
The court then had to decide what to do about the error. It looked at two options. It could vacate the rule only for the parties in the case. Or it could vacate the whole thing.
The court found it could not vacate the rule for the parties alone. The rule covered too many businesses. The rule applied to any form of negative option program, not just prenotification plans. So the court vacated the entire rule. It noted that the ordinary practice is to vacate unlawful agency action.
The panel added that the Commission's decision to bypass the preliminary regulatory analysis was not made in bad faith. This was a procedural failure, not a scheme. And the court took care to add that it "does not endorse unfair and deceptive practices in negative option marketing." Striking down the rule was not a blessing of dark patterns.
One more detail from the case. The court had earlier denied the petitioners' motion for a stay of the rule pending judicial review. So the rule was set to take effect while the case ran.
What the FTC did after the vacatur
The FTC did not walk away after losing in court. It took two steps.
First, it issued a conforming final rule. The conforming rule became binding on February 12, 2026. It rolled the Negative Option Rule back to the version that existed before 2024. Per the FTC's notice, a single practice falls within the rule's scope today. That practice is prenotification plans. The rule now carries the formal title Use of Prenotification Negative Option Plans.
The restored rule covers sellers of prenotification plans. Sellers have to lay out the plan's important terms in plain view before a consumer signs up. Sellers must act quickly on written requests to cancel under the rule. This applies to consumers who have met any minimum purchase requirements. It covers prenotification plan ads in all media. And it says a seller must not ship substituted merchandise without the express consent of the subscriber.
The second step came on March 13, 2026, when the FTC issued an advance notice of proposed rulemaking. The notice seeks public comment on the need for amendments to the rule. The FTC's notice asks whether it should use its FTC Act power to update the rule. The public can weigh in. Comments were due April 13, 2026. Anything that comes out of this process is a proposal, not a law. It would need its own rulemaking before it could bind anyone.
What still applies today
The vacatur killed the click-to-cancel rule. It did not kill the underlying law. Here is what still binds subscription sellers.
The restored prenotification rule
The FTC's current rule covers prenotification plans only. It does not cover other subscription types. If you run that kind of program, you must disclose material terms clearly before consumers subscribe. If a consumer has met any minimum purchase requirements, you must honor their written cancellation request promptly. You must not ship substituted merchandise without the subscriber's express consent.
ROSCA
The Restore Online Shoppers' Confidence Act still covers online negative option sales. Under ROSCA, a seller must clearly and conspicuously disclose all material terms before obtaining the consumer's billing information. It requires express informed consent before the charge. And it requires simple mechanisms to stop recurring charges. The vacated rule itself said its core duties already existed under other laws. Those laws are section 5 of the FTC Act, ROSCA, and the TSR. The court striking down the rule did not touch those statutes.
Laws on automatic renewals in the states
State automatic renewal laws are separate from the federal rule. These were never vacated.
California is the best example. Its Automatic Renewal Law still applies. A business must process an online cancellation promptly when the consumer uses the "click to cancel" link or button. It must promptly process a phone cancellation once the consumer states an intention to "cancel." The business must get the consumer's clear yes to the renewal offer terms. It must also get that yes before charging for a renewal. It must give an acknowledgment with the offer terms, cancellation policy, and how to cancel. It must give clear notice of any material change in renewal terms and how to cancel. It must send a pre-billing notice. The notice must say the renewal will continue unless the consumer cancels. Any email notice must include a link to the cancellation process. California's statute also permits cancellation by email. The company has to supply the address for that message. The customer can hit send without typing anything extra. And it says a business must let a consumer cancel a free-trial subscription before the consumer pays.
So California's Automatic Renewal Law has its own click-to-cancel duty, and the federal vacatur did not change it.
What to watch for next
The federal picture is not frozen. It is moving in three ways.
Track the FTC's next rulemaking effort. The window for comments shut on April 13, 2026. If the FTC proposes new amendments, a proposed rule and a final rule would come before anything binds you. Nothing in the advance notice is law. Do not build compliance plans around a proposal.
Track the states. State automatic renewal laws were never part of the federal rule, and California's law still sets its own online cancellation duty.
Watch the underlying statutes. ROSCA still requires simple mechanisms for the consumer to stop recurring charges. The Eighth Circuit also said it does not endorse unfair and deceptive practices in negative option marketing. The Commission may seek civil penalties, injunctive relief, and consumer redress for violations of ROSCA. The laws behind the rule never went away.
For businesses, the practical answer is this. Do not read the vacatur as permission to make cancellation hard. The honest fix is a simple way to stop recurring charges, which ROSCA requires for online sales. California customers also need an online cancellation processed promptly.
Status checked on 2026-10-17.
Sources
- Custom Communications, Inc. v. Federal Trade Commission, No. 24-3137, United States Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit (July 8, 2025) (Eighth Circuit) (8th Circuit) (Negative Option Rule) (FTC Act) (Federal Trade Commission Act)
- Rule Concerning the Use of Prenotification Negative Option Plans, Federal Trade Commission advance notice of proposed rulemaking, 91 FR 12318 (Federal Register, March 13, 2026)
- Revision of the Negative Option Rule to Conform to Federal Court Decisions, Federal Trade Commission final rule, 91 FR 6507 (Federal Register, February 12, 2026)
- Negative Option Rule, Federal Trade Commission final rule, 89 FR 90476 (Federal Register, November 15, 2024) (FTC click-to-cancel rule) (Rule Concerning Recurring Subscriptions and Other Negative Option Programs)
- Restore Online Shoppers' Confidence Act, 15 U.S.C. Chapter 110 (sections 8401 to 8405) (ROSCA) (Federal Trade Commission) (FTC)
- California Business and Professions Code section 17602 (California Automatic Renewal Law), as amended by AB 2863 (Stats. 2024, Ch. 515) (California) (BPC 17602)
No. The Eighth Circuit vacated the FTC's click-to-cancel rule on July 8, 2025. Here is the timeline, what still applies, and what comes next.