What an automatic renewal law is, and which states have one
An automatic renewal law is a state statute. It regulates subscriptions. It tells you what you must disclose before a customer signs up, what consent you must obtain, and how you must let the customer cancel. The federal ROSCA statute covers online negative option sales too. The state versions add their own specific duties.
Several states have one. California, New York and Minnesota have the clearest rules, so this guide walks through those three. Colorado, Virginia and Florida have their own versions. If you sell nationwide, check each state's statute that applies to your customers.
The duties these automatic renewal laws share
The three statutes below follow a similar skeleton. Your job is to fill it in for your own checkout.
Disclose. Show the renewal terms clearly before the purchase is complete.
Get consent. The customer must actively agree to the renewal terms. A contract clause that undermines consent does not count.
Acknowledge. Send a notice the customer can keep. It should repeat the offer terms. It should explain the cancellation policy. It should tell the customer how to cancel.
Provide a matching cancellation path. The customer must be able to cancel in the medium they used to sign up. If you take consent online, you must accept cancellation online.
California's Automatic Renewal Law
California's law sits in Article 9 of the Business and Professions Code, covering sections 17600 through 17606.
California's law says you must show the renewal offer terms clearly before you complete the subscription sale. You must get the consumer's express affirmative consent to those terms before charging for a renewal.
After signup, you must send an acknowledgment in a form the consumer can keep. It must include the offer terms, the cancellation policy, and how to cancel. California also requires a notice before you confirm the sale. It must say the renewal continues unless the consumer cancels. It must state the length and terms of the renewal period. It must give the amount or range of costs and how often you charge. It must list one or more ways to cancel. And it must include your contact information. An electronic notice must include a link to the cancellation process.
California sets a record-keeping rule that catches many sellers off guard. A business must keep proof of a consumer's affirmative consent for at least three years. Build that into your signup logs now, not after a complaint.
For online signups, California is blunt. If you let a consumer accept a renewal online, you must let them cancel online. They can cancel at any time. The method can be a prominently located direct link or button. It can be in the account, profile, or device settings. You may ask the consumer to log in or authenticate before cancelling if they have an account. But a consumer who cannot or will not authenticate online must still be able to cancel offline. They can use another method. You may offer a pre-written cancel email. The consumer can send it back without typing anything else.
When the consumer uses the click to cancel link or button, you must process the cancellation promptly. The same goes for phone cancellations: once the consumer states an intention to cancel, process it promptly.
You can read more about the cancellation side in our guide to the California click to cancel law.
New York's rule: cancellation in every medium you use to take consent
New York's automatic renewal law is General Business Law section 527-a. It adds a medium-matching rule with real bite. A consumer must be able to cancel at any time. They can use every medium the business allows for giving consent. If you take signups online, by phone, and in person, you must accept cancellations in all three.
New York also says you may not block a cancellation request. You may not refuse to acknowledge it. And you may not delay it without good reason. No unreasonably long hold queues. No ignoring the request until the billing date passes.
After consent, you must give a notice the consumer can keep. It must include the deadline to stop further charges and the ways to cancel.
Enforcement comes through the attorney general. The attorney general may ask a court for an injunction and restitution. A court may impose a civil penalty of not more than one hundred dollars for a single violation.
New York exempts a few groups. Banks, bank holding companies, credit unions and other licensed financial institutions are out. So are entities regulated by the department of financial services. Sellers and administrators of service contracts under the insurance law are exempt. So are businesses that run a franchise issued by a political subdivision of the state.
Minnesota's definitions: what counts as a renewal and what counts as clear
Minnesota's law, section 325G.56, mostly sets out definitions. But those definitions decide whether the rest of the law applies to you.
Minnesota defines automatic renewal as a plan. The plan renews the subscription on its own at the end of a set term. It defines continuous service as a plan. The plan keeps running until the consumer ends the agreement. Both are covered.
The law defines a consumer as any person who buys or leases goods, services, money or credit for personal, family or household use. A seller is anyone who advertises, solicits or takes part in consumer sales. That includes sellers, lessors, licensors and professionals.
Minnesota also spells out what clear and conspicuous means. Clear and conspicuous means larger type, contrasting type, font, or color, or text set off by symbols or marks. An audio disclosure is clear when you can hear and understand it. The volume and pace must be easy to follow. If your disclosure would not pass that test, it is not clear.
Minnesota spells out what the offer terms must cover. They must say the agreement continues until the consumer ends it. They must give the cancellation policy. They must state any minimum purchase obligation. And they must cover the recurring charges to the consumer's card or payment account, plus any change in the amount.
What the law forbids you from doing
Two California prohibitions stand out.
First, misrepresentation. California forbids lying about any key fact of the sale. That includes hiding that an automatic renewal is part of it. Say your checkout looks like a one-time purchase. If it signs the customer up for a subscription anyway, that is misrepresentation.
Second, contract terms that weaken consent. California also bans contract text that weakens the consumer's ability to give clear consent. The law forbids wording that interferes with, distracts from, contradicts or undermines that consent. You cannot bury a renewal clause under fine print, surround it with distracting text, or contradict it elsewhere on the page.
Never make cancellation harder than signup. Retention work belongs in the product, not in the cancel path. Fix the reason customers leave instead of trapping them.
Free trials, free gifts, and promotional pricing
California treats trials and gifts as renewal offers too. A free trial offer must clearly explain the price charged after the trial ends and how subscription pricing will change. A business must let a consumer cancel a free trial before the consumer pays.
Consent is required even for a renewal offer at a promotional or discounted price for a limited time. A free gift does not mean a promotional item that differs from the subscribed product. When both notice situations apply, only one notice is required. It is the notice for the free gift, trial, or promotional price situation.
If you run trials, read why free trials are not free for the card-rules side of this.
How to audit your signup and cancellation flow
Walk your own funnel and check each step against this list.
- Before checkout: are the renewal terms visible, clear, and close to the consent action? Would they pass Minnesota's contrast test?
- At consent: is the action clear and deliberate? Check for pre-checked boxes and any text nearby that says the opposite.
- After signup: does the acknowledgment cover the offer terms? Does it cover the cancellation policy? Does it cover how to cancel? Can the customer keep it?
- Records: are you storing proof of consent for at least three years?
- Cancellation: can the customer cancel in every channel where you accept signups? Is the online path a direct link or button, processed promptly?
- Trials: does the signup explain the post-trial price before the customer consents? Can the customer cancel before paying?
For a deeper walkthrough of the cancel path itself, see our guide to the cancellation flow. Other states have their own statutes. See the Colorado automatic renewal law, the Florida automatic renewal law, and the Minnesota automatic renewal law for their exact wording.
Fix what the audit finds before a regulator finds it for you.
Sources
- California Business and Professions Code section 17602 (California Automatic Renewal Law), as amended by AB 2863 (Stats. 2024, Ch. 515) (California) (BPC 17602)
- New York General Business Law section 527-a, Unlawful practices (automatic renewal) (New York) (GBL 527-a)
- Minnesota Statutes section 325G.56 (automatic renewal and continuous service) (Minnesota)
Automatic renewal law is a family of state statutes that share one skeleton. Here is what each one requires of your checkout and cancellation flow.