What "click to cancel" means for a seller
When merchants search for the "click to cancel law states," they are usually chasing a federal rule they heard about. The phrase got attached to a Federal Trade Commission rule. That rule would have required online cancellation for many subscriptions. That rule was published, then struck down by a court, so it no longer binds anyone. The phrase still points at something real, though. Online sellers in every state must give customers a simple way to stop recurring charges. Several states also have their own automatic renewal laws. Those laws set detailed rules for checkout and cancellation.
So the honest answer has three parts. A federal law called ROSCA applies everywhere. A set of state laws adds requirements on top of it. And the FTC rule that made headlines is gone, and the FTC's later request for comment on amendments is not law.
The federal baseline: ROSCA applies in every state
Before you look at state laws, start with the federal statute that applies in every state. The Restore Online Shoppers' Confidence Act, or ROSCA, covers negative option sales made online. It applies in every state, regardless of what state law says.
ROSCA requires three things of you. First, you must clearly and conspicuously disclose all material terms before you obtain the consumer's billing information. Second, you must get the consumer's express informed consent before charging their account. Third, you must provide a simple mechanism for the consumer to stop the recurring charges.
The FTC enforces ROSCA. The Commission may seek civil penalties, injunctive relief, and consumer redress for violations of ROSCA. Congress told the FTC to enforce the statute. It did not require the agency to write regulations under its section 18 rulemaking authority.
ROSCA also borrows its definition of a "negative option feature" from the FTC's Telemarketing Sales Rule. That rule is called the TSR. If you sold online and charges continue unless the customer acts, check your offer against that definition.
Why state laws matter on top of ROSCA
ROSCA is the floor, not the ceiling. It says you need a simple way for customers to stop charges. It does not spell out every detail of how your cancellation flow must work. State automatic renewal laws fill that gap. They set specific rules about notices, consent records, and how a customer cancels.
If you sell nationwide, you cannot treat one state's rule as the whole picture. Check each statute that covers your customers rather than assuming one state's rule fits all.
California: the most detailed state model
California's Automatic Renewal Law is the best example of how specific these state rules get. A consumer who signed up online must be able to end the renewal online too. They may cancel at will, and online is the only path you can require. The cancellation method can be a direct link or button. It must sit prominently in the account, profile, or device settings. You must process the cancellation promptly once they click it.
The same rule applies to medium. Cancellation must be available in the same medium the consumer used to activate the renewal. If they signed up on your website, they cannot be forced onto the phone to quit.
California also sets rules for the cancellation path itself. You may show a discounted offer during online cancellation. But it must sit beside a click to cancel link or button that stays on screen the whole time. The exit path has to stay visible the whole time.
Before the renewal starts, California requires you to get the consumer's express affirmative consent to the renewal offer terms. You must keep proof of that consent for at least three years. You must send an acknowledgment that includes the offer terms, your cancellation policy, and how to cancel.
Then there are the notices. California requires a pre-billing notice stating that the renewal will continue unless the consumer cancels. The notice must state the length and any added terms of the renewal period. It must state the amount or range of costs the consumer will pay, and how often. It must also state one or more ways the consumer can cancel. An electronic notice must include a link to the cancellation process.
California also covers free trials. You must let a consumer cancel a free trial subscription before they pay. The trial offer must also clearly explain the price charged after the trial ends. If you materially change the renewal terms, you must give clear notice of the change and how to cancel.
We cover California's law in more depth on its own page: California's click to cancel law.
Other state automatic renewal laws at a glance
Several other states have their own automatic renewal statutes. Each statute sets its own terms, and we cover them on their own pages.
Colorado has its own automatic renewal statute. Read the details on our Colorado automatic renewal law page.
Florida has an automatic renewal statute as well. See our Florida automatic renewal law page.
Minnesota's law, section 325G.56, sets its own rules for automatic renewal offers. Our Minnesota automatic renewal law page breaks them down.
If you operate in states beyond these, check each state's statute before assuming ROSCA is all you owe.
What the vacated FTC rule did and did not change
The FTC's click-to-cancel rule has a complicated history, and the dates matter for understanding where you stand today.
The FTC published the final rule on November 15, 2024. It was called the Rule Concerning Recurring Subscriptions and Other Negative Option Programs. The rule pulled together requirements from the Telemarketing Sales Rule and ROSCA. Those requirements apply to negative option marketing. The FTC said its substantive requirements were already extant under section 5 of the FTC Act, ROSCA, or the TSR. In other words, the rule mostly restated duties the FTC believed already existed.
The rule did add specifics. The FTC said ROSCA lacks specificity on some points. It does not spell out cancellation procedures. It also leaves open the placement, content, and timing of cancellation disclosures. The rule filled those gaps. ROSCA requires marketers to provide simple mechanisms for the consumer to stop recurring charges. It applies to consumers who enroll in negative option plans online. The FTC also noted that a ROSCA-compliant simple telephonic cancellation may still take more time and effort than enrolling in the plan. The rule even treated carwash subscriptions bought online or through a mobile app as covered by ROSCA.
Then the rule fell. On July 8, 2025, the Eighth Circuit vacated the rule in case No. 24-3137. The court vacated the entire rule, not only as to the parties, because of the breadth of its coverage.
The story continued after the vacatur. The FTC's conforming final rule took effect on February 12, 2026 (91 FR 6507). After the Eighth Circuit's vacatur, the FTC restored the Negative Option Rule to the form it had before the 2024 Rule became effective. Next came a March 13, 2026 notice (91 FR 12318) inviting comment on the need for amendments. That notice is not law. Nothing from that process binds you.
So where does that leave you? ROSCA is current law and applies everywhere. The state statutes are current law in their states. The 2024 rule is vacated and gone.
For more on what the vacatur means, see what happened to the FTC's click to cancel rule.
Building a cancellation flow around current law
Under ROSCA and the state statutes that bind you today, a cancellation flow has a few fixed points.
At checkout, disclose the material terms before you take billing information. Get express informed consent to the renewal terms, not just to the purchase. Send an acknowledgment with the terms and cancellation instructions. Where state law requires it, send the required pre-billing notices.
At cancellation, give the customer a path that matches how they signed up. If they joined online, let them quit online. Keep the path short and keep it honest. Do not bury the cancel button behind retention screens that hide the exit.
Retention itself is fine. In California you can show a discounted offer during online cancellation only beside a click to cancel link or button that stays on screen. The cancel option must stay visible. The customer must always be able to finish quitting. The right way to keep subscribers is to fix the reason they want to leave, not to make leaving hard.
For a fuller walkthrough, read our guide to building a cancellation flow.
What to check in your own flow today
Audit your signup and cancellation path with these questions.
First, are all material terms disclosed before you collect payment details? Check the actual screen a customer sees, not what your team assumes it says.
Second, do you have proof of affirmative consent, and can you produce it years later? California expects you to keep it for at least three years.
Third, can a customer who signed up online cancel online, without a phone call? If your answer is no, that fails California's rule for consumers who accepted the renewal online.
Fourth, do you send the notices your customers' states require before each billing? Map where your customers actually live, not where you are incorporated.
Fifth, does your free trial explain the post-trial price clearly? See our piece on why free trials are not free for the traps there.
Sixth, when did you last walk through your own cancellation flow as a customer? If you have not done it this quarter, do it now. The laws that bind you are ROSCA everywhere, plus the state statutes where your customers live. Neither one is waiting for the FTC to finish its next rulemaking.
Sources
- Rule Concerning the Use of Prenotification Negative Option Plans, Federal Trade Commission advance notice of proposed rulemaking, 91 FR 12318 (Federal Register, March 13, 2026)
- Restore Online Shoppers' Confidence Act, 15 U.S.C. Chapter 110 (sections 8401 to 8405) (ROSCA) (Federal Trade Commission) (FTC)
- California Business and Professions Code section 17602 (California Automatic Renewal Law), as amended by AB 2863 (Stats. 2024, Ch. 515) (California) (BPC 17602)
- Negative Option Rule, Federal Trade Commission final rule, 89 FR 90476 (Federal Register, November 15, 2024) (FTC click-to-cancel rule) (Rule Concerning Recurring Subscriptions and Other Negative Option Programs)
ROSCA sets the federal floor for canceling subscriptions sold online. California, Colorado, Florida and Minnesota add their own automatic renewal rules.