Renewal Rules Directory ↓

FTC click-to-cancel rule delay: what applies now

As of

Switch within Click-to-cancel rule

What the click-to-cancel rule was and where it stands now

The FTC click-to-cancel rule delay is really a vacatur, not a delay. In 2024, the FTC published new rules. They would have made sellers let subscribers cancel as easily as they signed up. The Eighth Circuit threw those amendments out on July 8, 2025. The FTC then restored the older, narrower rule that existed before 2024.

So the 2024 click-to-cancel amendments do not bind you today. That is the short answer. The longer answer is that other rules may still bind you, and the FTC has asked for comment on possible new amendments.

The timeline: published, vacated, restored, reopened for comment

Here is the sequence, with each dated step:

  • November 15, 2024. The FTC published its amended Negative Option Rule in the Federal Register.
  • July 8, 2025. The Eighth Circuit filed its opinion in Custom Communications v. FTC, No. 24-3137. It granted the petitions for review and vacated the amended rule. The FTC says this happened shortly before businesses would need to comply with all parts of it.
  • February 12, 2026. The FTC's conforming final rule, published at 91 FR 6507, took effect. It put the old pre-2024 rule back in place. It also changed the rule's name back to Use of Prenotification Negative Option Plans.
  • March 13, 2026. The FTC put out an advance notice of proposed rulemaking, cited at 91 FR 12318. The notice asks the public for input on whether the Negative Option Rule should be amended. The comment window closed on April 13, 2026. This notice is a request for input, not law.

Why the Eighth Circuit vacated the 2024 amendments

The court's reason was procedural. It ruled that the FTC failed to follow procedural requirements under the FTC Act.

Petitioners challenged the rule on three grounds. They argued the FTC went beyond the power Congress gave it. The rule did not meet the law's tests for how specific and how common the problem was. They also argued the rule must be set aside because the Commission never issued the required preliminary regulatory analysis. The FTC pushed back. It said the rule fit the problem and rested on solid evidence.

The court agreed with petitioners on procedure. It found the FTC did a thin job of weighing other options. Its final analysis barely discussed them. The informal hearing never covered their costs and benefits. The court said the Commission's decision to bypass the preliminary regulatory analysis was not made in bad faith. But the slip still hurt the petitioners. Because the rule was so broad, party-specific vacatur was not feasible, so the court vacated the entire thing.

Two points matter for merchants. First, the court made clear that its ruling was not a sign of approval for unfair or deceptive negative option marketing. Second, the ruling left ROSCA and the state automatic renewal statutes in place. It does not create a permission slip.

What the restored Negative Option Rule actually requires today

The restored rule is narrow. The FTC's notice says the rule now covers only one thing: prenotification plans. If you do not run a prenotification plan, the rule does not reach you directly.

If you do run one, the rule says you must clearly explain the plan's key terms before anyone subscribes. It says sellers must act quickly on written cancel requests. This applies once the buyer has met any minimum purchase terms. It covers how sellers market these plans in every kind of media. It also bars sending substitute goods unless the subscriber clearly agrees to them.

Most subscription businesses, including gyms, apps, and SaaS, are not prenotification plans. The vacated 2024 amendments would have covered you. The restored rule mostly does not.

What still binds you after the vacatur

This is the part that matters. Even with the 2024 amendments gone, three layers of law still apply to your cancellation flow.

ROSCA. The Restore Online Shoppers' Confidence Act, which covers internet transactions, remains on the books, and the court's decision did nothing to it. It requires you to clearly and conspicuously disclose all material terms before obtaining the consumer's billing information. You must get the consumer's express informed consent before charging. You also have to let them end the recurring billing without hassle. The FTC has brought numerous cases alleging that hiding cancellation mechanisms is unfair or deceptive. The vacated rule itself said ROSCA and section 5 of the FTC Act already covered its main points. It also said ROSCA lacks specificity. It does not spell out how cancellation must work, or where, what, and when you must tell buyers about it. The rule's record said existing legal authorities fall short because they leave consumers unprotected from certain practices.

Section 5 of the FTC Act. Unfair or deceptive acts in commerce remain unlawful. The FTC's research found confusing labels delayed consumers trying to finish cancellation tasks. Sites that hide cancellation under labels like auto-renew or edit plan drew criticism. A cancellation flow built to confuse is still enforcement bait.

State auto-renewal laws. Several states have their own automatic renewal statutes. California, Colorado, Florida, and Minnesota each have their own auto-renewal laws. Each statute sets its own terms. If you sell into those states, start with our auto-renewal law overview, because requirements differ and the federal vacatur changes none of them.

What the FTC's comment request means, and doesn't mean

The notice asks whether the FTC should write new rules to update this one.

It does not mean a new rule is coming next week. An advance notice is an early step. A proposed rule, a comment period, and a final rule would all follow, and each takes time. It also does not mean the current requirements are suspended. ROSCA and the state statutes stay in force the whole way through.

What to do in your cancellation flow while the rulemaking plays out

Treat the vacatur as a chance to fix the reasons subscribers leave, not as a chance to add friction. Here is the practical checklist:

  • Make cancellation easy to find. Do not bury it under vague labels.
  • Let anyone who signed up online stop the recurring billing without a runaround, which is what ROSCA calls for.
  • Act on cancellation requests quickly.
  • Check which state auto-renewal laws cover your customer base and meet each one that applies.
  • Review your free trial conversion flow, since FTC investigations have included claims of misrepresenting offers as free when they were not.

If you want a deeper walkthrough of designing the flow itself, see our guide to cancellation flow. For more on why trial offers go wrong, read why free trials are not free. For the full story of the court decision, see the vacated FTC click-to-cancel rule.

The FTC has asked for comment on whether to amend the Negative Option Rule, and that request is not law. However that request turns out, measure your flow against ROSCA and against every state statute that covers you.

Sources

The 2024 click-to-cancel amendments were vacated and the old rule restored. Here is what binds your subscription business today.