Renewal Rules Directory ↓

FTC Click-to-Cancel Rule Vacated: What Still Applies

As of

Switch within Click-to-cancel rule

What happened: the 2024 amendments and the Eighth Circuit's vacatur

The FTC click-to-cancel rule was vacated, and the timeline matters if you sell subscriptions. The FTC published its amended Negative Option Rule in the Federal Register on November 15, 2024. The amendments would have set federal standards for how easy you must make cancellation.

They never took full effect. On July 8, 2025, the Eighth Circuit filed its opinion in Custom Communications v. FTC, No. 24-3137. The court granted the petitions for review and vacated the FTC's amended Negative Option Rule. The FTC says the vacatur came shortly before businesses would need to comply with all parts of the rule.

The FTC then cleaned up its own rulebook. A conforming final rule took effect on February 12, 2026, restoring the Negative Option Rule to the form it had before the 2024 amendments. The rule's full name went back to Use of Prenotification Negative Option Plans.

One more step is pending. The FTC's advance notice of proposed rulemaking was published at 91 FR 12318 on March 13, 2026. The FTC's advance notice of proposed rulemaking seeks public comment on the need for amendments to the Negative Option Rule. The FTC's advance notice set April 13, 2026 as the deadline for comments. An advance notice is not law. It is the first page of a long process, and nothing in it binds you today.

What the vacated rule would have required

The vacated amendments had a simple core idea. A seller must provide a simple mechanism for a consumer to cancel. That mechanism must be as easy to use as the one the consumer used to sign up. Quitting was never to take more effort than joining.

The rule spelled this out. A consumer who enrolls online must get an equally simple online cancellation experience. The online cancel path must be easy to find and use. You could not require an online enrollee to talk to an agent or customer service rep to cancel. If you offered phone cancellation, you had to promptly effectuate cancellations requested through a number answered during normal business hours. You could not impose any unnecessary or unreasonable cost for the call.

The rule called this symmetry in time, burden, expense, and ease of use. It also said authentication steps should not create a distinctly asymmetrical experience. Two-factor authentication was fine. The final rule also removed the treatment of saves in cancellation flows, which the proposed rule had included.

What is still law: ROSCA and the restored rule

The vacatur did not leave a blank space. Two federal rules remain, each with its own scope.

First, ROSCA. The court left the Restore Online Shoppers' Confidence Act alone, and it still binds sellers. If you sell to consumers online with a negative option feature, ROSCA applies to you.

Second, the restored pre-2024 Negative Option Rule. The FTC's February 12, 2026 conforming rule put the old text back, recodified at 91 FR 6507. It is a narrower rule than the 2024 amendments, but it is live law.

Underneath both sits section 5(a)(1) of the FTC Act, which makes unfair or deceptive acts or practices in or affecting commerce unlawful. The FTC has brought numerous cases alleging that hiding cancellation mechanisms is unfair or deceptive. That theory did not die with the vacatur. The vacatur removed the rule's specific standards. It did not touch section 5 itself.

State automatic-renewal laws that survived the vacatur

The vacatur was federal. It did nothing to state law, and state automatic-renewal statutes are fully in force.

Each state's statute sets its own cancellation terms. Read our California click-to-cancel law page for the details. See our pages on the Colorado automatic renewal law, the Florida automatic renewal law, and the Minnesota automatic renewal law.

If you sell nationwide, you cannot design one flow for the loosest state. Designing for the strictest state you sell into avoids rebuilding the flow state by state.

Why the vacated rule still matters for your cancellation flow

Here is the practical point. The 2024 amendments are vacated. Their usability standards bind no one today. Still, three things matter for your cancel flow.

One, each state's statute still applies, so check your flow against each one.

Two, the FTC's enforcement theory predates the rule. The agency has long argued that hiding cancellation is an unfair or deceptive practice under section 5. The rule's record noted that easy cancellation is an essential feature of a fair and non-deceptive negative option program.

Three, trapped subscribers do not quietly give up. The rule's record noted commenters who said they resort to disputing the charge with the card issuer, or canceling the card altogether. Chargebacks cost you money. A clear cancel flow is cheaper than the disputes a hidden one creates.

The FTC's own research found sites that hid the cancellation path under labels like auto-renew or edit plan. Those confusing labels delayed consumers trying to finish cancellation. If your account settings look like that, fix the labeling regardless of what any rule says.

What to do now: a practical checklist

The vacatur does not mean you can make cancellation harder. Do not read it that way. It removed a federal standard, and the pressure moved to state laws, section 5, and card networks.

A practical checklist:

  1. Make sure a subscriber who signed up online can cancel online, without a phone call.
  2. Put the cancel path where a person would look. Label it cancel, not auto-renew or edit plan.
  3. Match the effort of signup. If signup took two clicks, cancellation should be in the same range.
  4. Keep authentication light. Ask for no more proof than the sign-up asked for.
  5. Effectuate cancellations promptly. Do not keep charging a subscriber who already asked to stop.
  6. Check which state renewal laws apply to your customers, and build to the strictest.
  7. If you run free trials, be honest about what happens when the trial ends. Our page on why free trials are not free covers the traps.

For a fuller walkthrough of building the flow, read our cancellation flow page. For the court challenge itself, see our page on the click-to-cancel court challenge.

The rule is vacated. The work is not. ROSCA, state statutes, and section 5 all still apply to how you handle cancellation.

Sources

The Eighth Circuit vacated the FTC's click-to-cancel amendments in July 2025. Here is what that means for subscription sellers, and what still binds you.