Renewal Rules Directory ↓

New York Automatic Renewal Law: What Sellers Must Do

As of

Switch within State auto-renewal laws

What New York's automatic renewal law is

The statute is General Business Law section 527-a. It is a state law. A federal law, the Restore Online Shoppers' Confidence Act (ROSCA), also covers online sign-ups. ROSCA remains current law. This page is about what New York adds for your New York customers. For gym memberships, app subscriptions or software plans, this statute draws a line. Cross it and the attorney general can come after you.

The law says you must give the consumer a notice right after they consent to the automatic renewal. The notice must be one the consumer can keep.

The notice must include two things. First, the deadline to stop further charges. Tell the customer exactly when they must act to avoid the next billing. Second, the ways to cancel. List every path the customer can use to end the subscription.

A consumer must be able to cancel at any time through every medium you allow for giving consent. If a customer can sign up online, they can cancel online. If a customer can start a gym membership through your app, they can end it through your app.

The law also says you may not block a cancel request. You may not refuse to acknowledge one. And you may not delay one without good reason. If a customer asks to cancel, acknowledge it and process it.

Unconsigned goods

Say you ship goods the customer did not order. The consumer bears no cost or responsibility for shipping the goods back to you.

Who the law does not apply to

The statute carves out four groups. It does not cover a service run by a business with a franchise from a local arm of the state. It does not cover any entity regulated by the department of financial services. It does not cover banks, bank holding companies, credit unions, or other licensed financial firms. It also does not cover sellers and administrators of a service contract. The insurance law defines that kind of contract.

What happens if you break it

The attorney general enforces this law. The attorney general may ask a court for an injunction when the section is violated. The court can issue it without proof that anyone was actually hurt or lost money.

The court may make allowances to the attorney general and direct restitution in such a proceeding. The attorney general can take proof, sort out the facts, and issue subpoenas. A court may impose a civil penalty of not more than one hundred dollars for a single violation.

A checklist drawn from the statute

Here is a practical checklist.

  1. Send a keepable notice right after consent, every time.
  2. Put the charge deadline and every cancel method in that notice.
  3. Let customers cancel through every medium you accept for signup.
  4. Acknowledge cancel requests and process them without delay.

Do not charge the consumer for shipping back unconsigned goods.

On retention: the right way to keep a subscriber is to fix the reason they want to leave. Never make the exit harder. A cancel path that obstructs or unreasonably delays a request breaks the statute.

Want more on designing the exit? See how to build a cancellation flow. The FTC published its amended Negative Option Rule in the Federal Register on November 15, 2024. The Eighth Circuit's opinion in Custom Communications v. FTC, No. 24-3137, was filed on July 8, 2025. The Eighth Circuit vacated the FTC's 2024 amendments to the Negative Option Rule. The FTC's conforming final rule was published at 91 FR 6507 on February 12, 2026. After the Eighth Circuit's vacatur, the FTC restored the Negative Option Rule to the form it had before the 2024 Rule became effective. The FTC's advance notice of proposed rulemaking was published at 91 FR 12318 on March 13, 2026. It is not binding law. New York's statute is current, and so is ROSCA. Status as of October 17, 2026.

New York is one of several states with its own renewal statute. For comparison, read about the California click-to-cancel law, the Colorado automatic renewal law, the Florida automatic renewal law, and the Minnesota automatic renewal law. If free trials are part of your funnel, see why free trials are not free.

Sources

New York GBL 527-a sets rules for subscriptions sold to New York consumers. Here is what the statute requires of your business and what the attorney general can do if you break it.